Lots of sizzle, not enough steak

Zinger — Fri, 21 Apr 2006 18:03:05 -0400

Freakonomics : A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything

rating:
asin: 006073132X
binding: Hardcover
list price: $25.95 USD
amazon price: $25.95

This book has had a tremendous amount of buzz, and so I was curious as to what a 'rogue economist' had to say that was so interesting.

And indeed, the book has its moments, as when it compares realtors to the Klan and asks what McDonald's and a gang hierarchy might have in common. Perhaps most controversial is the author's contention that legalized abortion contributed to crime rate changes.

The economist does pose some interesting questions and then goes about answering them in a rational, strictly by the numbers fashion. The book prompts you to think about the real relationships underlying sociological phenomenon.

The book suffers though, from the lack of an overall theme and direction. Most frustrating is the fact that the book asks a fairly important question - do parents really have any impact on how their kids turn out? - and then fails to answer it. The book fizzles out on an analysis of naming patterns and the implications for your child's future. That section starts out being interesting, but carries on far too long.

Ponderfodder - social science

Lots of sizzle, not enough steak